Garden City, New York · Since 1958

Your day.
Made Supreme.

Square pies. Round pies. All the good stuff.
Pizza & Italian favorites on Stewart Avenue.

Download the Pizza Supreme app.
Your favorites are a tap away.

Pizza night, lunch on the go, or your usual order. The Pizza Supreme app brings the Garden City menu to your phone, ready whenever you are.

Your favorites, your way.
Browse pizza, pasta, heroes, and more. Customize your order right in the app.
Pickup or delivery.
Choose how you want your Pizza Supreme order to arrive.
Keep an eye on your order.
Follow your meal from preparation to pickup or delivery with order tracking.
Order direct.
Find app offers and quickly reorder your usual.

Let's talk food

The square side of pizza night.

Spinach and mozzarella, rolled in pizza dough.

Sauce, cheese, and a very good lunch.

A slice of Garden City

Keep it classic with a cheese pie. Go for a square. Add a chicken roll, a hero, or a plate of pasta. Find your kind of pizza night at Pizza Supreme.

More people. More Supreme.

From baked ziti and penne vodka to party heroes and salads, explore the catering menu for your next office lunch, family gathering, or celebration.