Pizza
Hot pies, simple classics, and crowd-friendly toppings for pickup or delivery.
Garden City Pizzeria
Pizza Supreme
Pizza, Italian comfort food, pickup and delivery from 678 Stewart Ave in Garden City.
Our Menu
Classic pizza-shop favorites for lunch, dinner, and game night.
Start with a hot pie, add a salad, pasta, heroes, appetizers, and sides, then send the order straight to the Garden City kitchen.
View Menu & Order
Catering & Groups
Planning food for the office, team, or family?
Call Pizza Supreme for larger orders, party pies, trays, salads, heroes, and anything else the table needs.
Local Pizza
Built for the Garden City regular.
Quick pickup on Stewart Ave when dinner needs to be simple, hot, and generous.
PickupOrder online for pizza, Italian favorites, and easy add-ons without making the night complicated.
DeliveryCall ahead for bigger orders, office lunches, team meals, and weekend family spreads.
CateringVisit Us
678 Stewart Ave
Garden City, NY 11530
Order online for pickup and delivery, or call the shop when you want help with a larger order.
Hours
- Monday
- 11 AM - 10 PM
- Tuesday
- 11 AM - 10 PM
- Wednesday
- 11 AM - 10 PM
- Thursday
- 11 AM - 10 PM
- Friday
- 11 AM - 10 PM
- Saturday
- 11 AM - 10 PM
- Sunday
- 12 PM - 9 PM
Salads & Add-Ons
Round out the order with something fresh.
Add grilled chicken salads, sauces, and sides to balance pizza night or build an easy lunch from the Garden City shop.
Add to Order